Latest News

Hot Issues
spacer
ATO hit list 2025 – Key Areas Under Review
spacer
Why Succession Planning Matters for Privately Owned and Wealth Groups in Australia
spacer
Benefits of a business plan
spacer
Roles and Responsibilities in a Business Partnership
spacer
Mixing business and pleasure? Be vigilant this tax season
spacer
30 June 2025 - Tax Checklist - Small (and Micro) Business
spacer
3 more GST fraudsters sentenced under ATO’s Operation Protego
spacer
Evolution of Boeing - 1916 - 2025
spacer
ATO - Targeted Areas of Focus 2024-25
spacer
6 ways to improve your business plan
spacer
Benchmarks for small business
spacer
Beware the early lodgment tax trap, CPA Australia warns
spacer
Tax lawyer flags compliance traps with family trusts
spacer
Superannuation on paid parental leave from 1 July 2025
spacer
Tax Time Checklists Individuals; Company; Trust; Partnership; and Super Funds
spacer
Comparison of various Animal Weights
spacer
2025 Tax Planning Guide Part 2
spacer
From 1 July 2025 ATO Interest is no longer tax deductible
spacer
SME confidence and conditions see uptick over Q1 2025, survey reveals
spacer
Depreciation expert urges property investors to leverage tax depreciation
spacer
Buy a business
spacer
Upskilling and self-education costs
spacer
How secure is your super account?
spacer
Freshwater Resources by Country 2025
spacer
Why Might a Lease Dispute Occur?
spacer
2025 Tax Planning Guide Part 1
spacer
$20,000 instant asset write-off
spacer
New Bunnings scam warning
spacer
The Largest Empires in the World's History
Article archive
spacer
Quarter 1 January - March 2025
spacer
Quarter 4 October - December 2024
spacer
Quarter 3 July - September 2024
spacer
Quarter 2 April - June 2024
spacer
Quarter 1 January - March 2024
spacer
Quarter 4 October - December 2023
spacer
Quarter 3 July - September 2023
spacer
Quarter 2 April - June 2023
spacer
Quarter 1 January - March 2023
spacer
Quarter 4 October - December 2022
Superannuation and independent contractors: fresh Full Federal Court guidance

 

In February 2022, the High Court handed down a landmark decision in ZG Operations v Jamsek, which clarified the test for determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor.

 

 

The High Court remitted the question of whether the workers were “employees” under the extended definition of that term in s 12(3) of the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (the SGA Act) back to the Full Federal Court.

In deciding that the relevant workers were not “employees” under the extended definition in s 12(3), the Full Federal Court determined that s 12(3) does not apply to an independent contractor relationship where the worker uses a company, trust or other service vehicle to contract with the putative employer instead of doing so in their personal capacity. This confirms the ATO’s guidance in Superannuation Guarantee Ruling SGR 2005/1.

Additionally, in determining whether a worker is an “employee” under the extended definition in s 12(3), the Full Federal Court has confirmed that a worker will not be taken to work under a contract that is “wholly or principally for [their] labour” in the following circumstances.

Finding

Comment

The contract is for labour and non-labour (eg the provision of substantial capital assets or the assumption of risk) components, and based on a quantitative valuation, the non-labour components predominate.

In many independent contractor relationships, the contractor may be required to provide their own tools and equipment. Whether the contract is principally for labour or alternatively the provision of capital assets and the assumption of material risks is likely to turn on a valuation of the labour and non-labour components respectively.

The worker has the ability to delegate the performance of work under the contract to other persons.

The party that bears the onus of proof will need to substantiate the value of the labour and non-labour components through evidence.

The worker is engaged under a contract for a “result”.

This finding is consistent with previous case law and ATO guidance. The workers had a contractual right of delegation in this case.

 

Employers are required to provide their employees with a minimum level of superannuation support (currently 10.5%) each quarter, otherwise the employer will become liable to pay the superannuation guarantee charge. An “employee” for these purposes includes an employee at common law.

The SGA Act also includes a number of provisions which extend the meaning of “employee”. Relevantly, s 12(3) of the SGA extends the meaning of “employee”, so that: “If a person works under a contract that is wholly or principally for the labour of the person, the person is an employee of the other party to the contract.”

This provision is broad and captures many independent contractor relationships. An entity that engages an independent contractor under a contract of this nature is required to provide the contractor with superannuation support (otherwise they will become liable to pay the superannuation guarantee charge).

Whilst there is nothing new about these conclusions at such a high judicial level, this is a prudent time to review independent contractor relationships.

Expansion of the superannuation net is inevitable.

 

 

AcctWeb

Liability limited by a Scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
© O'Brien and Partners 2024 - All Rights Reserved | 333 Canterbury Road, Canterbury VIC 3126 | Tel: 03 9509 3911 Site by Acctweb